Artisan Bread in “Five Minutes”

On Monday I picked up a copy of Artisan Bread in Five Minutes a Day, and after reading about half of it Monday night in bed I woke up Tuesday determined to become a master baker in five minutes. And not a second more, damn it, because I’m an American and we’re impatient!

Food Photography by St. Louis Photographer Jonathan Gayman

Artisan Bread Basic Dough Recipe: Making the Dough

The recipe in the book for the basic dough in the book basically goes against everything that I have learned thus far about baking. For example every recipe I’ve ever read about bread says that you have to knead your dough for about six weeks to activate the gluten. The five minute recipe does not. In fact they specifically tell you not to knead. The basic concept is that you make a large-ish batch of dough at the beginning of the week (estimated time to produce: 15 minutes) and then cut off loaf sized handfuls whenever you’re ready to bake. The kneading is replaced y this procedure which gluten-coating thing. I’ve read four times and still don’t quite get how it works. Essentially you form the loaf with the un-kneaded dough and dust the dough ball with flour, which “coats” the ball in gluten. I understand the mechanics but I just don’t get why it works. But fear not, says I, I will plunge in without a complete understanding. Because after all, I’ve done that with really hard, complex, and non-five-minute recipes, so nows not the time to wimp out. So here I go.

8:30am: In lieu of a dough bucket I dug out a plastic box from the Container Store which had formerly held some ties (which I never wear) from my closet.

8:45am: After losing a quarter of an hour worrying that my box was too small, looking up new containers to buy online, going back to stare at the box I have, and several more minutes fretting that the world might end if my box proved too small, I was decided to go ahead with the dough.

8:50am: I measured out three cups of filtered water and heated them on my stovetop to 100 degrees. As a side note I should point out that we got rid of our microwave when we left New York with the intention of buying a new one, but never got around to doing it. I haven’t even missed it.

8:52am: I poured the water into my plastic box and added 1.5 tablespoons each of yeast and salt. Stir to mix.

8:53am: I add in 6.5 cups of all purpose flour. I used a half cup measure which fits through the opening of my flour jar, so 13 scoops leveled off with the back of a knife. I was a little surprised to see the scoop and level method, since most recipes call for exact weight measurements. My parents taught me the scoop and level method when I was a kid, so this step seemed very natural.

Once I added in all the flour I mixed it all up, first with a wooden spoon, then with my hands. I occasionally ran some warm water over my hands to ease the mixing. Also, the dough seemed a bit dry, so I thought the little extra water would help.

9:02am: All of the flour incorporated into the liquid resulting in a sticky dough. It seems more dry than I was expecting, but I’m determined to follow the directions correctly this time and see how it goes. Non-air-tight lid goes on box.

9:03am: Stare at completed dough in box. Turns out the dough doesn’t do tricks. Drink coffee and eat another chocolate chip cookie for breakfast. More staring at the box of dough. Finally decide to do something else for the two hours it’s supposed to take to rise.

Total time spent making dough to this point: 17 minutes. This puts me at 2 minutes over par for the recipe. If you include the fifteen minutes of anxiety-fueled inaction worrying about the size of my box and then the coffee, cookie, stare-at-dough-like-a-moron break I was 18 minutes over par.

11:22am: I checked on the dough just under two and a half hours after I finished mixing it. The dough rose considerably, but seemed to have stopped rising at this point, almost perfectly filling the 5 quart container. I make the decision to go for a run before putting it in the fridge.

12:30pm: Back from the run, dough goes into the fridge. The book says that I should let it sit overnight in the fridge, or wait at least three hours before making a loaf from my dough as the dough will be a lot easier to work with when it’s cold. Additionally the longer amount of time it spends in the fridge the more interesting the flavor will be apparently.

Food Photography by St. Louis Photographer Jonathan Gayman

Artisan Bread in Five Minutes

Ok, so on baking day I woke up a bit earlier than usual (perhaps because of my pre-baking excitement), and headed to the kitchen to make my first loaf of bread. I have to admit, my expectations were quite high.

7:13am: Dusted my peel with cornmeal in preparation for the bench proof (or rest time as the book calls it)
7:14am: Pulled the dough from the fridge, dusted the top with flour then grabbed a hunk to make my first loaf. I had a serrated knife at the ready to cut it loose, but found that the hunk I pulled out of the container tore right off. This may be an indication that the dough is too dry.
7:15am: I shaped the dough into a boule shape and put it on the peel to rest. I used the gluten-coating method as prescribed by the book, which surprisingly worked like a charm. I got a smooth surface almost immediately.

Entire process of making the loaf took me just over three minutes!

A few of notes on the dryness of the dough:

  • The books calls for a container that isn’t air-tight for making the dough so that it doesn’t explode. But if air can get out, it will take moisture with it. Especially considering that over the course of the two weeks I would be worried that a lot of moisture would escape. More research/experimentation is needed.
  • I wonder if my Oxo measuring cups are slightly larger than they should be. I am finding that all of my bread recipes have been too dry. Perhaps this is an argument for using the weight system after all.
  • I wonder if I could use my spritzer and spray the remaining dough in the fridge to add some moisture or if the dough is ruined once it’s too dry.

7:58am: Bread goes in the oven with along with a cup of water dumped into a brownie pan for the steam.
8:15am: A quick peak and it looked like the bread had cracked open. I’m guessing this is due to the dryness.
8:29am:Timer for 30 minutes went off, and since the color looked good and the loaf felt firm I took the bread out of the oven. Turns out that had cracked along the seams of my slashes. Other than that it looked amazing and smelled fantastic.

After Action Report

I ended up making a second loaf later in the day in the form of a baguette. Same dough, same basic method, only I used whole wheat flour on the peel and didn’t dust with flour when I slashed it. Also the resting period what shorter, resulting in a denser and heavier loaf.

Dr. Fiance and I ate both loaves of bread for dinner along with a kickass salad (more on the salad later) and a bottle of cheap but tasty wine. For my first time out with the “five minute” recipe, I was more than satisfied. The bread was perfect for tearing off of the loaf to sop up extra salad dressing, and was perfectly fine plain. I’m sure a dap of rich salted butter would have made it even better, but I consider it a success that additional condiments were completely optional.

While there is certainly room for improvement, the bread was by far the tastiest bread that I’ve made (excluding a couple of recipes I have for rolls). The crusts were strong and chewy, while the crumb was light and flavorful and not too dry at all, despite my earlier fears. Both loaves, but especially the baguette were a little dense, and I’m going to stick with my theory that a dough that is more moist will fix that by aiding the final rise a bit. To be sure, however, the five minute recipe is going to be a staple in my kitchen for a while.


  • Jessie
    November 18, 2010 at 8:41 am

    I tried this over the weekend (only made a half recipe) and had similarly delicious results. Amazingly easy. I am looking forward to testing their assertion that the dough gets more flavorful with age.

    The pizza recipe is calling to me…

    • ShootToCook
      November 18, 2010 at 9:50 am

      We made pizza a couple of weeks ago, with mixed results. The very high heat was little scary, and Xina burned her arm trying to save her pizza that I pushed off the pizza stone trying to get it out. They tasted great though. As for letting the dough age in the fridge, I’m not sure how to do that because at the rate we’re going a four-loaf batch is only going to last two days!

  • Wednesday Night Goddess Salad « Shoot to Cook
    November 18, 2010 at 9:11 am

    […] Gear « Artisan Bread in “Five Minutes” […]

  • […] was chatting over IM with a friend about my exciting new artisan bread in five minutes I’d just made with virtually no effort, and the following thought occurred to me: why […]

  • Gratuitous Bread Porn « Shoot to Cook
    December 9, 2010 at 11:45 am

    […] post, but I decided to share a gratuitous bread photo of today’s loaf. This is a new batch of dough that contains both rye and whole wheat flour and looks simply […]

  • James Beard Home Style Bread « Shoot to Cook
    January 26, 2011 at 8:08 am

    […] a 1lb loaf of five minute artisan bread for dinner each night has become an easy habit to fall into. I always have about four loaves worth […]

  • […] thing that I have routinely stocked up on is baking supplies, obviously. In addition to my standard five minute bread I’ve been making all sorts of different types of breads for sandwiches and special events. […]

  • […] way out of the problem. The quick and dirty method that I’m referring to is, of course, the five minute a day method which involves a high dose of yeast, which means quick rising, easy to make bread. It is […]

  • […] since I started making the “five minute a day bread” back in the fall, I’ve been pretty much going through the motions. I tweaked the […]

  • Marianna
    March 15, 2012 at 10:38 am

    I’ve never tried this 5 minute method, but my mom swears by it. I do have a tip for the steam issue: in the book Ratio by Michael Ruhlman he recommends cooking boules in a dutch oven. Oil the bottom of the dutch oven, proof the dough in it, and cook it with the top on. This captures the natural steam and removes the need for a secondary water source in the oven. I’ve tried it once and it worked out pretty well. Very crispy crust, and still moist on the inside.

    • ShootToCook
      March 15, 2012 at 11:07 am

      Thanks for the tip! You may also want to check out my post on slow-fermentation dutch oven bread. It’s not much more work than the five-minute bread, although it does take 24 hours to proof – but the hands-on time isn’t much more. And the results are amazing.


Leave a Reply